In “Duel in the Sun,” we witness actor Gregory Peck’s impressive ability to transcend typecasting and deliver a memorable performance as a morally complex character.
This film tells the story of Pearl (Jones), who is sent to live with her father’s cousin, Laura Belle McCanles (Gish), after witnessing her mother’s murder at the hands of her father.
Upon arriving in Texas, she encounters Jesse (Cotten) and his younger brother Lewt (Peck.
While initially welcomed by Jesse, she finds herself the target of advances from Lewt despite her discomfort.
Jennifer Jones’ portrayal of Pearl is characterized by overacting, which adds an excessive layer to an already exaggerated plot.
The subplot involving the railroad development feels underdeveloped and results in a grand production with notable moments but a disjointed narrative.
However, Peck’s performance as the villainous Lewt stands out as a highlight of the film.
His portrayal of a highly flawed man with compromised morals who eventually goes on the run for his actions showcases his versatility as an actor.
The film features impressive visuals and a compelling score, but its overly dramatic script prioritizes intense emotions that often overshadow other story elements.
This imbalance results in a climax that feels lacking and even borders on the silly.
Despite these flaws, “Duel in the Sun” remains an interesting watch for its unique blend of fascinating visuals and captivating performances, although sometimes for the wrong reasons.